election 2016

The great debate ... Brandis v Dreyfus ... Attorney General is called a disaster, a liar, a failure and delusional ... Federal judges make unprecedented entry into election campaign calling for more to be allocated to the courts to handle domestic violence at the "coal face" ... Parliament misled by the attorney general ... Read more ...  

Justinian's news stories

Attorney General Brandis asserts political influence over Solicitor General Justin Gleeson ... Government access to the Solicitor General to be controlled by AG ... More outsourcing of constitutional advise to the private bar ... Ideological agenda at play ... Read more ... 


Search Justinian
Free Newsletter sign-up

 

From the friends of the ABC

Justinian Columnists

Murder into manslaughter, and maybe back again ... The Baden-Clay case in the High Court ... Artemus Jones claims that appeal courts have a history of handing out softer sentences to perpetrators of violence against women ... Populist outcry verses learned legal commentators ... Read more ... 



Twitter

This form does not yet contain any fields.

    LEIGH SALES: But I think people watching this also want to know that you're listening to them and what those polls tell you is that there's something that you're doing which they don't like.
    MALCOLM TURNBULL: Well why don't you ask me a question about it?
    LEIGH SALES: Well I am asking you a question about it. What do you think - what do you think - what do you think has happened that you have lost that ginormous chunk of approval?
    MALCOLM TURNBULL: Leigh, I am not going to be drawn into that kind of introspection ... 

    Interview with PM Turnbull on the ABC's 7.30, June 8, 2016 ... READ MORE >>


    Justinian Featurettes

    Ian Hancock is the biographer of Tom Hughes QC, a hero of the Sydney bar ... He has submitted to Justinian's probing, intimate questions on the eve of the book's publication ... Biographing a biographer ... Read more ... 


    Justinian's archive

    Tubby's in the firing line ... It's a wheeze on the High Court ... Japes fly thick and fast from droll judicial wags ... There were two in two days ... From Justinian's archive of transcribed morsels ... Read more ... 


     

    « Hermann and the juicy file | Main | Messenger remains unshot by the High Court »
    Tuesday
    Feb262013

    A painful day

    The hidden role of pre-menstrual syndrome at the bar ... Man-flu seems a perfectly acceptable ground for non-appearance ... The role of the hot-water bottle ... Junior Junior on secret women's business  

    ONE of the drawbacks of being a barrister is that you can't outsource your job. 

    Like wedding photographers or top class surgeons, you can't wake up on the morning of a hearing and decide you aren't bothered to go to work.

    In fact, if you wake up and you are sick as a dog, you still have to drag your sorry tail to the court and put on a show to remember.

    The only excuses for not turning up are death, paralysis (at least paraplegia – even then the ease of acquiring a wheelchair would be factored in) or gaol.

    So, the other morning when I woke up with the worst women's pain of my life and a court appearance in two hours, I knew what was going to happen.

    I managed a semi-shower, but no breakfast. I put on my most comfortable, but court-appropriate, outfit and I filled a hot water bottle for the trip. 

    Normally, I'm pretty fussy about my appearance. No lady barrister is seen operating in a man's world without looking her best.

    But, there I was traipsing up King Street holding a hot water bottle to my abdomen. 

    I arrived in chambers and promptly hid in my office with my hot water bottle until 15 minutes before court.

    Time to leave.

    I put the hottie on my chair and picked-up my handbag.

    Then, naturally, I burst into tears.

    In my time at the bar I have never once cried in chambers - welcome to the charming world of PMS.

    Who knew that sanity could be contained in a rubber bladder? Knowing that the hot water bottle would be cold by the time I returned from court was just too much for my hormone-addled brain.

    I considered sticking it up my dress and trying to look a little pregnant during my appearance.

    The fear of it dropping out of my skirt and having to explain myself was too much to bear and I left the bottle where it was.

    The appearance itself was mentally painless. And a good thing too as severe abdominal pain tends to be a little distracting.

    I promptly returned to chambers, wrote my report for the day and then disappeared - home to bed.

    I wondered how my male colleagues cope with illness. Everyone knows man-flu causes males of the species to be completely incapable of movement or rational thought, so how do they make it to court when really afflicted?  

    I once had surgery. My surgeon popped his head in the same afternoon, for a little under 10 seconds, to let me know all had gone well and he would see me tomorrow to go through everything. 

    Tomorrow came, but my surgeon did not.

    The nurse contacted him, to be told that he had man-flu.

    I found it odd that no one batted an eyelid that he had failed to keep an appointment due to a mysterious ailment.  

    Needless to say, I was discharged home never having seen him again. 

    Maybe at the bar a quick call, man-to-man (barrister-to-judge) is sufficient to have the daily list reordered to accommodate the sorry soul.

    I suspect that such accommodations would not be forthcoming for creatures such as me, regardless of how forward thinking our profession believes it has become.

    Until the day that PMS is as acceptable an excuse as man-flu, for missed appointments or rescheduled appearances, our profession will not have achieved gender equality.  

    Reader Comments (3)

    This is an irritating post on a few levels. It is difficult to know if the author is being tongue in cheek about any of it. All it seems to be doing is reinforcing all of the stereotypes women at the bar rail against. The need for a female barrister to look her best in a male dominated world? Puh-lease. Man flu v PMS? Double puh-lease. Surely there are more interesting anecdotes about life at the junior bar as a female than what is presented here.

    February 27, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterLisa

    The notion that a man could call another man to explain being ill and gain any kind of special consideration or preferential treatment is paranoid and fanciful.

    March 2, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterJeremy

    Please no more of the gender comparisons that have ailed the last few posts - it all seems a bit self-pitying.
    Give us some more of the gossip which made the early posts great!

    March 4, 2013 | Unregistered Commenterchica at the bar
    Member Account Required
    You must have a member account on this website in order to post comments. Log in to your account to enable posting.