Search
This area does not yet contain any content.
Justinian News

Delay update ... "Extraordinary and excessive" delay - by the litigants ... Contest on costs ... Getting to grips with Qld industrial law takes time ... What is a "worker"? ... What is an "injury"? ... Justice Jenni frigging around ... Slow grind for earnest Circuiteer ... From judges' associate Ginger Snatch ... Read more >>

 

Politics Media Law Society


The End Of The Affair ... Lord Moloch’s bid for more Fox News fans … The Wall Street Journal rallies the MAGA base …Will the old rogue abandon his journalists? … Is “bawdy” the right word here? … The Deep State plumbs the depths … John and Stanley Roth’s generosity to loving causes ... Read on >> 

Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

From the cutting room floor...Handsy Heydon goes to Perth ... Celebrity tour ... Conferenceville ... Dicey's job application speech from 2002 ... Other High Court judges mocked as "vegetables" ... Mason CJ ridiculed ... Speech bowdlerised for public consumption ... Courage of conviction MIA ... From our National Affairs Correspondent ... Read more >> 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


 

 

Justinian's Bloggers

London Calling ... Sizzling in the Old Dart ... Story of the complaining law graduate ... Tattle Life brought to book ... Beckham family feud over royal gong ... Floyd Alexander-Hunt's postcard ... Read more >> 

"What you are not being told by the media anywhere is that the death toll likely would not have been as high if it wasn't for DEI."

Charlie Kirk, American conservative and conspiracy theorist on the Texas floods ... The Charlie Kirk Show, July 9, 2025  Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

Tootsies with Planet Janet ... Water Softener and the Planet ... Further details of the width and depth of their relationship ... Chief Justice of the ACT grants Justinian's application for access to more documents ... A barrage of text messages and phone calls throughout the Drumgold investigation ... Collated reporting ... Read more >> 


Justinian's archive

Being chased by a dog called Rhetoric ... Justice Virginia Bell on rhetorical devices and barristering ... It seems to be a male thing ... Distractions from the truth ... Tulkinghorn asks, where would the bar be without bad rhetoric? ... September 14, 2012 ... Read more >> 


 

 

« Rosenblum v Foreman | Main | Orifice politics »
Saturday
Jan012000

Some good, some turnips

Pricks on the bench ... Kevin McFee JP (High Court candidate) gives an overview of Justinian's Judges Survey from March 1995 ... Anger uncorked ... From our Déjà Vu Department  

Natural selectionNever in living memory has there been such a lively response on a matter of public importance. Justinian's Judges Survey has struck a rich lode of deep-seated concern, damnation and dismay.

We have had a very high response rate to our questionnaire which was sent out late last year. Subscribers were asked to nominate who, in their experience, they considered to be the three best and the three worst judges, and to give reasons.

Some of our subscribers have gone to enormous trouble in preparing very thoughtful answers, which reveal concerns about the calibre, behaviour, selection and capacity of some of our judicial icons.

Within the profession there is obviously frustration about the performance of some judges. The comments we received about behaviour are riddled with words like:

"Lazy ... unsuitable temperament ... rudeness ... lack of intellect ... mad bad and dangerous ... delusions of grandeur ... pomposity ... wastefulness ... bias ... chauvinism ... bullying ... slowness ... corruption ... ineptitude ... pedantry ... gutlessness ... gullibility ... neanderthal ... a disgrace to the bench ... simply appalling ... maniacal."

Other comments dealing with standards, selection and quality are also upsetting:

  • "The standard is declining, appointment is now influenced by minority groups – gays/feminists/you name it. Legal ability and common sense are ignored in appointments. As a result the standard has slipped during the last 10 years." 
  • "If the standards of conduct, behaviour and performance which judges apply to solicitors, and to a lesser extent barristers, for the purposes of discipline and striking off, were applied to judges and magistrates, the ranks of both would be decimated."
  • "They can only be brought into the 21st century by a wholesale process of reform - de-robing and gender education might help. Judges should be prevented from retiring early, resuming (improperly) their sobriquets as QC, ensuring fat dollars as arbitrators and taking superannuation at the same time." 
  • "To often judges move from cloister to cloister – brilliant at GPS, establishment university, High Court judge's associate, maybe Oxford, articles at establishment firm, bar then proving to be pricks on the bench." 
  • "Some good, some turnips. Selection process should be changed completely." 

[Maybe it's time for another Justinian Judges Survey?] 

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Editor Permission Required
You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.