SEARCH
Justinian News

Latest from Brucie ... Bruce Lehrmann v Commonwealth Special Minister of State & Maj Gen Paul Brereton (NACC) ... See SMH >> ... Application for relief under s.39B of the Judiciary Act ... Read more >>

Politics Media Law Society

Perils of the Defamatorium ... Lovely Linda Reynolds’ “victory” leaves her underwater … Politics, sex, law, and money … Injuries galore … The art of Tottling … Where’s the serious harm? … Trust me … Jurisdictional backwater ... Read more >> 

Free Newsletter
Justinian Columnists

Act of gracelessness ... Kathleen Folbigg's miserable ex gratia payout ... Comparable awards in other miscarriage cases ... Weasel words from the NSW Premier ... Need for a proper system of compensation assessment ... Procrustes in a lather ... Read more >> 

Blow the whistle

 

News snips ...


Six new judges for Div 2 of the FCFC ... More >>

Justinian's Bloggers

Postcard from London ... Summertime - And the living' is easy ... Votes for 16-year olds ... Paralegal's theft by pen ... Spy helping British intelligence from his job at Border Force ... Super-injunction comes out of the shadows ... Feed them strawberries and cream ... Floyd Alexander-Hunt files from Blighty ... Read more >> 

"Where are the glossy magazine spreads traversing what Reynolds and Brown went through? Where is the march for justice in support of these two brave women? Where is the apology from Gallagher and Wong? Where is the inquiry into the $2.4m of taxpayer money we now know was paid by the Department of Finance on the basis of false statements?"

Linda Reynolds is the victim here, not Brittany Higgins who was raped on Reynold's ministerial couch ... From Janet Albrechtsen, leader of the Reynolds' cheer squad ... The Australian, August 29, 2025 ... Read more flatulence ... 


Justinian Featurettes

News from the Defamatorium ... End of the golden era ... Reputational warriors rack up huge bills ... Unhappy outcomes ... Costs eat the damages ... Al Muderis, Reynolds, Lehrmann ... Statutory tort of privacy to the rescue ... Finding holes in the media exemption dyke ... O.F. Wilde reports ... Read more >> 

Justinian's archive

The Tamil Times ... The corruption wars ... Blitzkrieg from The Australian's legal affairs man ... Campaigns to sink ICAC and 18C ... Battles lost in the trenches ... Where are they now? ... Extravagant fulminations ... From Justinian's Archive, April 8, 2017 ... Read more >> 


 

 

« Queen's committee sifts submissions in NSW | Main | The horizontal effect »
Wednesday
Mar122014

Stacking the deck 

Payback time in Queensland ... Attorney General's scheme to get criminal appeal judges of the right flavour ... Splitting the Court of Appeal ... Sidelining Margaret McMurdo ... Nothing very subtle here 

McMurdo P: sidelined

THERE was an interesting story in today's Bowen Hill Bugle about a scheme of Queensland attorney general, (Jiving) Jarrod Bleijie, to split the Court of Appeal.  

It's devilish stuff. 

The split would reduce the authority and remit of Court of Appeal President Margaret McMurdo. 

Apparently, the idea is to create a Court of Criminal Appeal (à la NSW). 

This would reverse the earlier consolidation of the appeal courts with the aim of allowing Bleijie to plant a judicial pal as president of the new CCA. 

Margaret McMurdo has not been consulted by the Sunshine Coast conveyancer. She has written to him saying she was "anxious to discuss the matter". 

There's been no response from Bleijieville. 

The creation of a separate Court of Criminal Appeal was floated at the bar conference on the weekend. 

There's a decided pong about the whole thing, with every indication that the scheme is "to get" McMurdo P and install a second president on a relative small bench of six appeal judges. 

In due course, we'll see an appeal court with two divisions, two chiefs, one of which is sidelined from doing criminal appeals (the area where McMurdo excels) with the other branch in step with the government's lawn-order agenda. 

The bar and the government are in furious agreement about the need for a split appeal court. 

Given the primitive quality of the Newman government's sense of wild justice this can be seen as little more than a payback for the appeal court's temerity in refusing Bleijie's appeal in the Fardon case and declaring his executive detention law unconstitutional. 

The fact that husband Philip McMurdo is president of the Judicial Conference of Australia probably doesn't help. 

The JCA issued media releases ever so gently chiding the government's pet chief magistrate Tim Carmody and Jarrod's legislation for executive detention of sex offenders. 

Come back Denver Beanland. All is forgiven. 

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.
Editor Permission Required
You must have editing permission for this entry in order to post comments.